Guide for Tenants: Deposit Replacement vs. Traditional Deposit Schemes

The beginning of a tenancy can be something of an emotional roller coaster. Abruptly packing your life into boxes and most likely living out of them can pile on the stress. 

Tenants Contents Insurance from just £3.12

  • ✓ Covered up to £30,000
  • ✓ Flexible monthly policies
  • ✓ No hidden fees
Get a quote
First time Buyer mortgage

On top of the exciting parts, there’s always that ominous shadowy figure lurking round in the background too. The most unwelcome housewarming guest… the dreaded holding deposit.

Whilst this charmer has got significantly less scary since 2019, when the Tenant Fee Ban shrunk it down to a slightly more manageable size – just five weeks’ worth of rent allowed now – it’s still a hefty whack to find when you’re paying out for moving costs. 

But there is some good news: as a tenant, you now have options. Not only can you now slice this beast down to size (one week security deposit payment anyone?) but you also have the opportunity of spreading this payment out over the entire length of your tenancy agreement. And your landlord benefits too, getting better deposit cover – 12 weeks’ instead of five.

All of a sudden those spooky figures look, well, quite manageable really. Let’s go over how this works. 

Traditional Deposit Scheme

First let’s break down how traditional deposit schemes work. tHey’ve been around forever and work really nicely – if you’ve ever rented before you are probably vaguely familiar with them, but possibly don’t know the ins and outs.

For tenants

  1. Requires you – the tenant (or a guarantor, a company, or local authority – someone from your ‘camp’) – to provide funds upfront to your landlord or letting agency. This can be up to the equivalent of five weeks’ worth of rent.
  2. You are responsible for paying your rent on time and in full, and if there are no damages to the property, you would hope to receive the deposit back, in full.
  3. The renting deposit must be returned within ten days if there are no concerns.( However, if there have been any hiccups along the way, you could expect a deduction from your cash lump sum.)
  4. Once you have left the property, they will do a check out inspection, which is usually then compared to the inventory you signed off when you moved in.
  5. The tenancy agreement should mention issues which would trigger a deposit deduction – but you should be pragmatic about this – if there are any glaring issues, you’ve mislaid a sofa that came with the property, for example, your landlord can rightly make a claim to replace this.

For landlords

  1. Landlords are legally required to safeguard and protect your deposit with one of three governmentally backed deposit protection schemes: the Deposit Protection Service, MyDeposits, and the Tenancy Deposit Scheme
  2. Money must be protected within 30 days of tenants paying it over, and they (and whoever else has contributed) must receive a bundle of details, known as Prescribed Information.
  3. Provide a Prescribed Information with details about – where the deposit has been protected ,how the deposit has been protected ,how the deposit will be managed at the end of the tenancy, the deposit protection certificate, terms and conditions of the chosen scheme
  4. Landlords are covered by deposits in case tenants miss their rent payment
  5. The deposit offers up to five weeks worth of protection, to cover up for any unsolicited expenses

If there are disagreements ,the scheme has independent adjudicators who can then look at the case and make a decision whether or not the damage is justified as ‘fair wear and tear’ and if the landlord has a right to withhold some of the cash. Fair wear and tear is things like grubby marks on walls, stains on carpet, signs of wear in kitchens etc  – the sort of damage you would expect to come from living in a property. 

Damage that may cause deposit loss may be cigarette burns in carpet, holes made in walls, or doors missing from kitchen units.Rent arrears are also liable to get the security deposits chunked off, but that’s to be expected!

The independent adjudication team will make a decision, and your landlord has to stick by this. They may not like it, you may not like it, but it removes any emotion from proceedings. Once adjudication is complete, the remaining deposit will be returned to the tenant. Once it has gone to an adjudicator, the deduction is up to them. 

So, in a nutshell, that’s your traditional scheme. There’s a lot to be said for it, but it isn’t for everyone, and there’s no denying the upfront cost. For many tenants (and savvy landlords) deposit replacement options are where it’s at. We’ll explain why…

What is a Deposit Replacement Scheme?

Contrary to the traditional deposit approach, the Deposit Replacement Scheme wipes out the financial hit of the one-off, upfront payment. What’s not to love? It is a great deal considering that it allows you to reduce your upfront costs, spreading the cost of your holding deposit across the length of your tenancy. 

And it’s a small cost to spread, you’re only paying for one weeks’ worth of rent, instead of the traditional five. 

A deposit replacement scheme is a deposit in name, but is a totally different beast to the  traditional option. Your money isn’t going to be sat, static, waiting for you to finish your tenancy. It’s not there earning interest for anyone, it’s not bubbling away in a bank account, minding its own business and achieving very little. Instead, the principle is that you and your landlord are covered by an insurance policy that insures you for the amount specified (Mashroom’s policy specifies the equivalent of 12 weeks’ rent).

However there are two main costs to consider – paying the premium costs, just like paying off your car insurance in little chunks and you don’t get the money back.

With the second option at least you can be sure that –, you don’t lose a whacking great amount at the start. If you DO use the policy (a house party leaves your property trashed the day before you move out, for example), you’ve paid tiny amounts monthly, and you and your landlord are financially covered.

Traditional DepositDeposit Replacement
Huge upfront costLower upfront cost
Doesn’t require a premiumPay a price premium
Get the money back (in theory)Don’t get the money back

It’s a process we use a lot with other insurances – contents insurance being one that we use a lot to describe it. You don’t pay your contents insurance expecting to need it, but if someone nicks your TV, you’re super glad you did.

But what if something goes wrong ? Good question. 

You may have noticed that there’s no deposit scheme to adjudicate if things get tetchy between you and your landlord at the end of the tenancy. 

Whilst we can’t speak for other offerings — here at Mashroom we work with RICS, a globally recognised professional body to help solve disputes, so the principle is much the same (other products may have other similar options). Your landlord will still have to provide evidence, and there’s no sneaking things past this lot, if the facts aren’t there, the facts aren’t there.  

That said, whilst the payment terms are flexi, your responsibilities within a rent free deposit  scheme are still the same. Rent, bills, and compensation for any potential damages are still very much the norms and need to be followed wisely.

What’s better traditional deposit or deposit replacement ?

For many, the oldies are really the goodies. Many people love the familiarity of the traditional deposit scheme, and hey, that’s ok. However, alternative methods are growing and it’s always great to be aware of the trends and innovations that help create a better experience for both parties. 

Trends keep changing and so will tenant schemes. If a larger upfront fee, done and dusted, is more beneficial to you, then by all means go for it! However you do prefer to manage your money in monthly or smaller cycles, understand that there are other options on the table for you as well. 

It’s empowering to know that you can manage your finances and put your mind at ease with these two options that allow you to take control. The choice  on this one really is in your hands – it is your landlord/agent’s duty to provide you with a choice.

At Mashroom, we’re here to help. If you’d like some more information on our deposit replacement scheme, or any of our tenant initiatives, contact us HERE today, or book a consultation with one of our friendly agents.

Comments 0


Tenancy deposit
Money shield
Local heroes
Approved code
Property ombudsman
Open banking
Mashroom is an appointed representative of Adelphi Insurance Brokers Ltd. Adelphi Insurance Brokers Ltd is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). Their Financial Services Register number is 594620, with permitted business activities being introducing, advising, arranging, dealing as agent, assisting in the administration and performance of general insurance contracts and credit broking in relation to insurance instalment facilities. You may check this on the Financial Services Register by visiting the FCA’s website, or by contacting the FCA on 0800 111 6768

Mashroom Mortgages is a trading name of Emash Ltd which is an appointed representative of Mortgage Advice Bureau Limited and Mortgage Advice Bureau (Derby) Limited which are authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.
Your home may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on a mortgage or any debt secured upon it. A fee of up to 1% of the mortgage amount may be charged depending on individual circumstances. A typical fee is £495.
Emash Ltd. Registered Office: 21 Navigation Business Village Navigation Way, Ashton-On-Ribble, Preston, Lancashire, England, PR2 2YP. Registered in England Number: 11735831.